Pages

Sunday, 15 April 2012

National Under Renewed Scrutiny


Britain's gruelling Grand National has came under renewed fire after the death of two horses at the notorious Becher's Brook fence prompted passionate calls for a radical safety review.

Cheltenham Gold Cup winner Synchronised and According to Pete were both put down after falling at Becher's Brook, taking the total of fatalities at this year's three-day Aintree meeting to three.

The tragedy overshadowed a thrilling race where 33/1 shot Neptunes Collonges became the first grey to win the most famous race on the British calendar since Nicolaus Silver in 1961 when it pipped Sunnyhillboy in the closest finish in the National's 173-year history.

Two horses also died in the 2011 Grand National, leading officials at the course to modify the daunting Becher's challenge.

"The death of two horses at the Grand National, bringing the total to three at the Aintree meeting, is totally unacceptable," Gavin Grant, the chief executive of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) told the BBC.

"In its current format, the risks to horses are not appropriate and we want an urgent examination of the Grand National, including a number of fences such as Becher's Brook, where horses are continuing to die despite safety improvements."

Synchronised had already shown signs of distress before the race started when the nine-year-old unseated veteran jockey Tony McCoy.

The horse, who was looking to become the first horse to win the Gold Cup and Grand National since the legendary Golden Miller in 1934, broke away and it was several minutes before animal and jockey were reunited, delaying the start of the race by 10 minutes.

In a damage-limitation exercise, Aintree owners, as well as the British Horseracing Authority (BHA), moved to confront the gathering storm.

Tim Morris, the director of equine science and welfare for the BHA, said: "In both cases the horse incurred a fracture to the leg and the humane option was to put the injured horses down."

He added: "We will examine closely the circumstances which led to both incidents. The key data from these accidents will be collated, as is the BHA's policy in the event of any serious equine injury.

"Each year the BHA and Aintree review all incidents which occur during the Grand National meeting and consider what measures can be taken to address the risk of a repeat in the future."

David Muir, an equine consultant to the RSPCA, told The Guardian that drop fences - those like Becher's on one side of which the ground is lower than on the other side - should be removed before next year's race.

"I think the Grand National has a future if it changes and makes the risk factors lower and more acceptable," Muir said.

"If racing is to continue, racing must realise that people are concerned about horse fatalities on racecourses and the impetus to reduce the risk factor has to be greater."

For Synchronised's trainer, Jonjo O'Neill, the drama brought back the awful memory of when he rode Gold Cup winner Alverton in the 1979 National.

That horse also came to grief at Becher's and was also put down.

The winning owner, John Hales, spoke movingly about the mixed emotions he had at his horse's victory, 14 years after his much-loved gelding One Man died in the race.

"It split the family coming here," Hales said. "My wife was 50-50, my daughter couldn't face it. She has gone show jumping and is overcome with emotion."

Winning traner Paul Nicholls cautioned against making too many changes to the race.

"When you are in competitive sport, whatever you do, motor racing, hockey there is an element of risk," Nicholls told the BBC.

"The worst thing you can do is to go too far. You make the fences smaller, they go faster and you get more fallers.